Paper Mache` vs. Creative Paper Clay vs. Paper Clay Recipe! (2024)

For those of you who work in figurative sculpture, or are art doll makers, or just like to putz around in an artsy way this post is for you. If you don't fit into the categories above this post may just be a yawn. Sorry.

The following is a comparison of my experiences using three different products. Paper mache`, Creative Paper Clay, and paper clay recipe.

Paper Mache` vs. Creative Paper Clay vs. Paper Clay Recipe! (1)

This picture is a good example of how I like to mix up my mediums. The round flower is Creative Paper Clay. The 3-petal blossom is made from the paper clay recipe found on line. Both of these flowers adhered quite well with out any glue to the paper mache` background.

In my Cloth and Clay group I have a discussion going about a paper clay recipe vs. purchasing the manufactured paper clay. I wanted an alternative to the little bricks and my dependency on whether or not my local hobby stores would have it in stock or not. And, truthfully, at the time with a rather large sculpture in mind I knew I would eat through those little blocks in a wallet blowing way.

In asking around one of my fellow Cloth and Clay members hooked me up with a link to a website and a paper clay recipe. Scroll down through my posts-the link is in there somewhere. I cooked it up, messed it up, fixed it again and now have grown quite used to it and use it regularly. So I thought I would share with you what I have learned in the process.

Paper Mache` vs. Creative Paper Clay vs. Paper Clay Recipe! (2)

I usually start my projects with a wire armature. This satisfies the mechanical side of my abilities. Nothing like twisting and cutting wire and then wrapping all kinds of tape and stuff around it! And to satisfy the miser in me I use a base layer of paper mache`. It fills up nooks and crannies quickly when used thickly, is really quites strong, and can be smoothed out to be very thin layer (HA! Paper thin as a matter of fact! I kill myself with my obviousness!) that will allow the texture of the mesh/screen to show through.

Then on the surface layer I would use paper clay- as we all know- it sands up beautifully, paints easily and is an all around joy to work with. I discovered along the way that if you didn't want to sand you could use a paint brush and water to smooth out the surface. That discovery led me to create a 'slip'- really watered down and mixed up paper clay which I then brush on the surface. This creates an interesting grainy finish. By the way, I have kept this slip in an airtight container in my frig. for months now, no sign of mold or mildew. I'm surprised no one has tried to eat it.

Paper Mache` vs. Creative Paper Clay vs. Paper Clay Recipe! (3)

This flower is uses a big round ball of paper clay smooshed on the surface of paper mache`. I needed the paper clay's dryish consistency to maintain the shape of each petal as I dug into the clay and lifted the petal up. Neither paper mache or the paper clay recipe would have given me this fine detailed result. The paper clay recipe does not have the same finish as Creative Paper Clay. It is an entity of its own, truly a mix between paper mache` and Creative Paper Clay. It dries up hard. It reminds me of a cast you'd see on a broken arm. I haven't used it in final stages; I've stuck with the Creative Paper clay. But the recipe is more 'pose-able' than paper mache and I can manipulate it into small shapes such as flowers or glop it on where I need structural strength. I get more done with it for less $$$ than the Creative Paper Clay. Its a real time saver because its already mixed up and waiting for me. I have not been successful storing mixed paper mache`.

Paper Mache` vs. Creative Paper Clay vs. Paper Clay Recipe! (4)

I've also found that, using the same tools I normally do I can get a fair amount of detail into the paper clay recipe. It dries fairly quickly and your working time can be extended by adding water- either spritzing it on or dabbing with a paint brush. By the way, the paper clay recipe can be smoothed out with a paint brush while still wet. It will however maintain a textural surface, don't expect it to be perfectly smooth.

I keep the paper clay recipe in a ziploc bag in the fridge next to the slip. It feels like bread dough. I actually prefer to let it set up a few days before I use it. I have a tendency to not squeeze all the water out of the TP. and usually have to add more of the other ingredients to make up for it. I don't have specific amounts to pass along. If you are used to Creative Paper Clay- keep the texture of that in mind as you make your decisions. For, myself, I enjoy making up the recipe as I feel even more creatively bonded to the future piece of work. I'm also pleasantly taken back to the time when I was a new mother as the linseed oil's fragrance reminds me of the Desitin lotion I used on my daughter's diaper rash. Just a side note there.
So there it is, a three way tie as I could not do what I do with out all three of them now. Feel free to share your experiences- I'm always up for learning new things! I'll check for spelling tomorrow, right now my former Desitin user wants to cuddle! Goodnight, all!

Paper Mache` vs. Creative Paper Clay vs. Paper Clay Recipe! (2024)

FAQs

What is the difference between paper clay and paper mache? ›

In conclusion

So, let's round off the question of "what is the difference between papier mache and paper clay?". Papier mache is paper and glue (plus fabrics on occasions) and if you add plaster to the equation it becomes Carton Pierre. Paper clay is something else altogether.

Which paper mache recipe is the strongest? ›

Form our years of making paper mache at summer camp and in the classroom, we find that flour is strong and durable. PVA glue, like elmer's glue, of course is also strong and durable, but as flour is so cheap and also eco friendly, I would always put the flour paper mache recipe first.

Can you sculpt with paper mache clay? ›

This home made clay can be use din the same way as the store bought clay to either sculpt whole forms, or add details to projects made out of paper mache strips. It is not as smooth as the Creative Paper Clay, but still works pretty well.

What's better than paper mache? ›

Plaster cloth is a fun material for kids to create amazing sculptures. It's a less messy alternative than paper mache and engaging for a variety of ages.

Does paper mache clay dry hard? ›

Paper mache clay dries really hard, and sanding it is a pain in the rear. Plus, you need to wear a mask, because you don't want the fine powder in your lungs. And you probably want to do it outside, because that fine dust will go all over your house.

How many layers should you put on paper mache? ›

You can do two or three layers at a time if you bake the project to dry it. This also helps if you have a non porous mould under the mache, as the inner layers will take much longer to dry from one side only.

How many layers is best for paper mache? ›

You will have to cover the form with at least three or four layers of paste and paper to make it nice and strong. You must also let the form dry before adding each additional coat. Be generous with the paste.

What can you do with paper mache clay? ›

Step 3: Use the Paper Clay for Crafts

I primarily use it as a coating for upcycled crafts; I've smushed it onto foam, plastic, metal, glass, and more…and because it has wood glue in it, it's adhered to the surface as it's dried. As with most materials, the thicker the layer you apply, the longer it'll take to dry.

What is the easiest clay to sculpt with? ›

Polymer clay remains soft and pliable and won't dry out. You can bake polymer clays in a conventional oven and your creation will still retain its color, shape and size after curing. Polymer clay is the perfect choice for beginners, but it's suitable for crafters of all skill levels.

What does paper mache not stick to? ›

The most important thing to note is that, depending on your glue or paste, most paper mache adhesives won't stick to plastic. You can use this to your advantage when replicating objects.

What can you use instead of paper mache paper? ›

If you don't have newspaper to hand, you can substitute it with loo roll, tissue paper or cardboard. Paper mache is made from strips of paper stuck together with the surprisingly strong mache glue mixture.

Is paper mache just paper and glue? ›

One of the most common, and easiest, ways to create paper mache is to use glue and water as the paste. A few different types of glue will work, but most people use wood glue or white Glue-All. Using glue is very similar to using flour, but it creates a stronger structure that is less likely to rot.

What is clay and paper mache? ›

The paste of clay and paper is known as paper-mache. It can be used for making masks, figurines, sculptures and ornaments.

What is paper clay best for? ›

Paper clay can be made from left over throwing slip from wheel throwing. It is widely used by potters to repair cracks in dry, conventional clay, as well as dry paper clay. Thinner and taller work can be built with partially dry or completely dry paper clay.

What is paper clay made of? ›

'Paperclay' is essentially a mixture of clay and cellulose fibres. The cellulose fibres in paperclay can come from either new or recycled paper pulp, derived from plants such as cotton, hemp, flax, linen or trees (1). The cellulose fibres burn out of the clay body during firing.

What are the two types of paper mache? ›

There are two methods to prepare papier-mâché. The first method makes use of paper strips glued together with adhesive, and the other uses paper pulp obtained by soaking or boiling paper to which glue is then added.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Nathanael Baumbach

Last Updated:

Views: 5464

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (55 voted)

Reviews: 94% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Nathanael Baumbach

Birthday: 1998-12-02

Address: Apt. 829 751 Glover View, West Orlando, IN 22436

Phone: +901025288581

Job: Internal IT Coordinator

Hobby: Gunsmithing, Motor sports, Flying, Skiing, Hooping, Lego building, Ice skating

Introduction: My name is Nathanael Baumbach, I am a fantastic, nice, victorious, brave, healthy, cute, glorious person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.